🌌 Embracing the Mystique: Bilā Kayfa in Islamic Theology
Definition, Etymology, and Meaning
Bilā Kayfa (بِلَا كَيْفَةَ) is a vital term in Islamic theology, especially in discussions regarding the nature and attributes of Allah (God). The term translates to “without how” or “without asking/knowing how.” It is used to dissuade delving into the anthropomorphic portrayal of God by maintaining that God’s essence and actions are beyond human comprehension and should not be questioned or rationalized in earthly terms.
Etymology: The phrase stems from Arabic:
- بِـلَا (bilā): “without”
- كَيْفَةَ (kayfa): “how”
Background and Historical Facts
The use of Bilā Kayfa is historically significant, especially within the Aqidah (creed) discussions of early Islamic scholars. During the early Islamic period, particularly within the Mu’tazilite and Ash’arite debates, scholars grappled with interpreting the Qur’an and Hadith. This concept was staunchly advanced by the Ash’arites and Maturidis to oppose literal interpretations that implied any form of human-like attributes to Allah, thus safeguarding the essence of Tawhid (the oneness of God).
One of the most pivotal proponents of Bilā Kayfa was Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal (780–855 CE). He strongly argued against anthropomorphic interpretations and safeguarded traditional beliefs about Allah’s nature by asserting that asking ‘how’ Allah’s attributes manifest is beyond human realms and should be left unquestioned.
Cultural Differences and Similarities
Islamic Traditions:
- Sunni Islam: Predominantly follows the concept, particularly in Ash’arite and Maturidi traditions.
- Shi’a Islam: Also embraces a non-anthropomorphic interpretation of God’s attributes but may differ in theological nuances.
- Sufi Practices: Stress on overcoming egocentric intellectual pursuits, often emphasizing spiritual comprehension over rational dissection.
Interfaith Comparisons:
- Christianity: Analogous concepts exist, particularly regarding the Trinity, but explaining God’s essence still sparks theological debate.
- Judaism: Some similar ideas exist, such as in Kabbalistic traditions where God’s nature and ways are viewed as entirely distinct from human comprehension.
Synonyms, Antonyms, and Related Terms
Synonyms:
- Tanzih (تَنْزِيه): Declaring abstract transcendence, purifying God’s attributes from human-like symbolism.
- La Taifun (لاَ طَيْفُون): No comprehension, not speculating the divine attributes.
Antonyms:
- Tashbih (تَشْبِيه): Anthropomorphism, likening God attributes to that of humans.
- Jismiyyah (جِسْمِيَّة): Embodiment, asserting corporeal existence to God.
Related Terms:
- Tawhid (تَوْحِيد): Oneness, unity of God.
- Aqidah (عَقِيدَة): Creed, theological beliefs.
- Mutashabihat (مُتَشَابِهَات): Ambiguous verses in the Qur’an that require contextual interpretation.
Exciting Facts
- Influence: The Bilā Kayfa concept allows Muslims to maintain a sense of awe and mystery surrounding the divine, fostering a humble submission to Allah’s will.
- Qur’anic Basis: The concept is paralleled in certain Qur’anic verses like Surah Al-Ikhlas that emphasize Allah’s incomparable uniqueness.
- Modern Rationalism: Attempts to reconcile modern science and theology still evoke this concept, underscoring an unchartered territory for human cognition.
- Philosophical Depth: Philosophers like Al-Ghazali utilized Bilā Kayfa to balance between rational thought and divine acceptance.
Quotations
-
Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal: “Our duty is to believe and accept the divine message as it is, without asking how.”
-
Ibn Taymiyyah: “Affirm Allah’s attributes as proclaimed in the scriptures, but withdraw from the ‘how’.”
Suggested Literature for Further Studies
- “The Incoherence of the Philosophers” by Imam Al-Ghazali
- “Foundations of Islamic Theology” by William Montgomery Watt
- “Heading Toward the Man-Made Soup: Reconciling Science and Islam” by Muzaffar Iqbal
Quizzes
Thank you for embarking on this profound journey into understanding the divinity beyond questions. May a deeper comprehension lead to immense spiritual enlightenment.
Kamilah Sharif, October 11, 2023
