Marxism and Islam are ideologies originating from different historical and philosophical backgrounds, yet with notable intersections, particularly in their collective emphasis on social justice and critique of economic disparity.
Comprehensive Definition
Marxism and Islam represent two systems of thought where diverse forms of Marxism regard social ills resulting from the oppression of the poor by the wealthy (class conflict). This often contrasts with the ideal Muslim society called to fight for social justice, equality, and the eradication of poverty. While Marxism is typically associated with atheism and a materialist worldview, many Muslims relate implicitly or explicitly with Marxist critiques of societal structures, although often rejecting its secularism.
Etymology & Background
Marxism derives from the works of Karl Marx (1818-1883), particularly his critique of capitalism and materialistic interpretation of history. Islam, from the Arabic root “s-l-m,” fundamentally means “submission” (to God’s will) and encompasses a comprehensive way of life guided by the Qur’an and Hadith.
Historical Context
Muslim intellectual and political engagement with Marxism began post World War II, gaining prominence during the 1960s and 1970s. This epoch was marked by anti-colonial sentiments and a pursuit of independence, justice, and equity, where leaders and intellectuals found common goals in these seemingly disparate ideologies.
Cultural Similarities and Differences
-
Similarities:
- Advocacy for social justice.
- Emphasis on equity and eliminating economic disparities.
- Critique of exploitative structures and oppression.
-
Differences:
- Marxism’s atheistic stance clashes with Islam’s deeply theistic foundation.
- Marxist historical materialism versus Islamic belief in divine transcendence.
Synonyms and Related Terms
- Communism: A broader term related to Marxism, signifying a classless society.
- Islamic Socialism: Ideological framework merging Islamic principles with socialist thought.
Exciting Facts
- In the 1960s and 1970s, several Middle Eastern countries, notably Egypt under Gamal Abdel Nasser and Algeria under Ahmed Ben Bella, integrated Marxist elements into their governance and policies while retaining an Islamic social context.
- Prominent Islamic thinker, Ali Shariati, fused Marxist and Islamic philosophies to advocate for social change in Iran.
Quotation
“Marxists and Muslims alike share an abhorrence of inequality; one attributes it to class struggle, the other to ethical malaise. Both yearn for a just world.” — Hassan El-Yousef
References & Literature Suggestions
- “Islamic Marxism: The Fusion of Faith and Revolution” by Irving Zeitlin.
- “Islam, Politics, and Social Movements” by Edmund Burke III and Ira M. Lapidus.
Farewell Thought
By exploring Marxism within an Islamic context, readers can uncover a rich, complex interchange of ideas driving social change and the blending of seemingly contradictory ideologies for common social wellbeing. Don’t merely look at ideologies in isolation but seek to understand how diverse perspectives work together for humanity’s greater good.
